Behind Every Closing Are Partners Who Care
image (14)

Our Story
Your trusted title agency from start to close. 

Buying a home is one of life’s biggest milestones, but the closing process can often feel overwhelming. That’s why Mutual Title Agency was founded in 2004 to make closings simpler, smoother, and more people centered.  

From the beginning, our philosophy has been clear: people come first. Whether you’re a homebuyer, seller, real estate agent, or loan officer, our team is here to deliver a title and escrow experience built on clarity, speed, and proactive communication. We keep every party informed with timely updates and work tirelessly to resolve issues before they become obstacles.
 

Our mission is clear: to turn the closing table into a celebration, not a stress point so your real estate journey ends on the high note it deserves.

Your Partners In Closing
Here are the trusted professionals you’ll meet along the way ready to guide you from start to close.

Frame 204 (16)
Kim Croftcheck
President
kcroftcheck@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204
Beth Dzurilla
Sales Manager
bdzurilla@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (1)
Dominic Corstange
Sales Representative
dcorstange@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (2)
MaryAnn Finnegan
Title Officer
mafinnegan@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (3)
Jennifer Emerson
Escrow Officer / Post Closing SME
jemerson@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (4)
Cathy Seneff
Escrow Officer
cseneff@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (5)
Stacey Gonzales
Escrow Officer
sgonzales@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (6)
Katrina Lee
Escrow Officer
klee@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (7)
lana Carr
Escrow Officer
lcarr@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (8)
Claire Deighton
Escrow Officer
cdeighton@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (9)
Darwin McMurray
Escrow Officer
dmcmurray@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (10)
Melissa Pokatello
Escrow Assistant
mpockatello@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (11)
Alexandria Weisenseel
Escrow Assistant
aweisenseel@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (12)
Amy Elliott
Disbursement Coordinator
aelliott@mutualtitleagency.com
Frame 204 (15)
Jennifer Mancine
Title Policy Typist
jmancine@mutualtitleagency.com

Ready to start closing? So are we.

Submit your order online and we’ll take you across the finish. Have questions? Let’s chat!